A forensic psychological evaluation is a specialized assessment conducted to address psychological questions relevant to a legal matter. These evaluations may inform decisions involving criminal responsibility, competency to stand trial, sentencing, parental fitness, personal injury claims, and other legal proceedings.
Unlike a traditional clinical evaluation, which typically focuses on understanding an individual’s symptoms, establishing diagnoses, and informing treatment recommendations, a forensic evaluation is designed to answer specific questions within a legal context.
The forensic psychologist’s role is not to advocate for a particular legal outcome. Rather, it is to provide objective, scientifically grounded opinions based on psychological evidence, clinical expertise, and the relevant psycholegal standards.
Assessing parenting capacity, child safety, and family dynamics.
Explore →
Assessing sexual behavior, risk, and treatment needs.
Explore →
Evaluating risk of future violence in legal and clinical contexts.
Explore →
Assessing mental state at the time of an alleged offense and its relevance to criminal responsibility.
Explore →
Assessing competency to stand trial, waive rights, or make legal decisions.
Explore →
Exploring psychological factors relevant to sentencing and mitigation.
Explore →
Evaluating psychological effects of injury and related damages.
Explore →
Providing clear, objective testimony based on sound psychological science.
Explore →
We draw on extensive knowledge of psychiatric, neurodevelopmental, cognitive, and trauma-related conditions to investigate symptoms, evaluate competing explanations, and understand their functional implications.
We focus on the specific legal questions at issue, examining how psychological findings relate to an individual's legally relevant behavior, abilities, and functioning rather than relying on diagnoses alone.
We integrate psychological testing, records, collateral information, interviews, and behavioral observations while carefully considering response style, conflicting evidence, and the limitations of assessment methods.
Our conclusions are guided by the evidence, not by a preferred legal outcome. We explain the reasoning behind our opinions, address relevant limitations, and communicate findings clearly.
Tell us about your case and any important deadlines.
We’ll discuss your questions, records, and evaluation needs.
We conduct a thorough, objective evaluation.
You’ll receive a detailed report and, when needed, testimony.
Independent forensic psychological evaluations for attorneys, courts, agencies, and individuals in Salt Lake City and throughout Utah.
Defense attorneys, prosecutors, and other legal professionals.
Courts, judges, guardians ad litem, and child welfare agencies (e.g., DCFS).
Individuals referred for forensic assessment in legal proceedings.
Where psychology meets the law.
Join Dr. Casey Mangnall, founder of Utah Center for Psychological Services, for conversations with expert guests about psychological assessment, forensic practice, and the clinical science that informs legal decision-making.
A forensic psychological evaluation is an objective assessment conducted to answer a specific legal or court-related question. Unlike therapy, the focus is not treatment; it is to provide clear, evidence-based opinions that can assist attorneys, courts, or other decision-makers.
Forensic evaluations are objective and not treatment-focused. The evaluator does not serve in a therapeutic role and does not advocate for one side. Instead, the goal is to help answer a legal question by providing a well-reasoned, unbiased opinion based on multiple sources of data.
Although both may involve clinical interviews, psychological testing, and diagnostic assessment, they differ in purpose and scope.
A clinical evaluation typically focuses on identifying psychological conditions and developing recommendations to support the individual’s treatment or other needs. A forensic evaluation addresses specific psychological questions arising within a legal proceeding.
Forensic psychologists must also consider the potential influence of litigation on the information being reported, evaluate response style, and select assessment methods appropriate to the legal context. Their primary responsibility is to provide independent, evidence-based opinions rather than advocate for the person being evaluated.
Our evaluations are methodical, detailed, and grounded in multiple sources of data. Our expert psychologists go beyond surface-level conclusions, carefully integrating records, testing, interviews, and contextual factors to provide clear, well-supported opinions that are meaningful and usable in legal settings.
The process varies, but it typically includes a clinical interview, review of records, standardized psychological testing, and collateral interviews. All data are carefully integrated into a clear, comprehensive report that addresses the specific legal and/or clinical question.
Attorneys should consider a psychologist’s formal training in forensic psychology, experience with the relevant type of evaluation, and clinical expertise related to the issues in the case.
Forensic specialization may be developed through graduate training, internship, postdoctoral fellowship, supervised forensic experience, or board certification. Clinical expertise is equally important. For example, a personal injury evaluation involving psychological trauma requires a strong understanding of trauma-related conditions, differential diagnosis, and psychological assessment.
Attorneys should also consider how the psychologist approaches potentially unfavorable findings. A credible forensic expert must be willing to reach and communicate opinions that may not support the retaining party’s position.
A comprehensive forensic evaluation typically involves integrating multiple sources of information rather than relying exclusively on an interview or a single psychological test.
Depending on the referral question, this may include psychological testing, medical and psychiatric records, legal documents, collateral interviews, developmental history, and behavioral observations.
Forensic psychologists must also evaluate the consistency and credibility of available information, consider response style, and understand the limitations of assessment instruments in forensic contexts.
When information conflicts, the evaluator’s responsibility is not simply to select the account that appears most convincing. Instead, the psychologist must examine possible explanations for those discrepancies and consider how they affect the strength and limitations of the resulting opinions.
REVIEWED BY
Licensed Psychologist │ Utah License: 12377684-2501
View Professional Credentials →
You don’t have to do this alone. Healing is possible and we’d be honored to support you.